« why are there no news media stringers in iran? | Main | bunker busters on the cheap ... (first off, steal the plans from scandia labs) ... »

July 06, 2009

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Phil

I'd like Barney Frank and Sarah Palin to duell. That way whoever died we'd still be ahead. In fact with any luck they'd both be killed.

john jay

phil:

i've not much use for barney frank, regarding him as about as worthless as tits on a boar hog.

i rather like sarah palin.

i believe that i take vigorous exception to your remarks about her. she has been a breath of fresh air in the american political scene.

i hope she garners the presidency some day, and consider it if not entirely like then at least quite possible.

so there.

john jay

p.s. i do not understand your animus to her? care to explain?

john jay

" ... if not entirely likely, then ... "

Justin Credible

I would very much like to hear from someone why Sarah Palin garners so much scorn from folks.

is it the pro-life thing? Is it her desire for energy independence, fiscal restraint, secure borders, smaller government, lower taxes, or what? just would like someone to explain it to me.

Cordially,
Justin

john jay

justin:

i wish that i had said it so well.

john jay

Proof

There's a lot of merit to that idea. I always favored a lottery for one member of Congress to be lined up against the wall and shot each term.
Anyone not willing to lay down his life for his country need not apply!

Dueling, however gives each a sporting chance and would permeate society as a whole!

john jay

proof:

laughing. there are 435 of 'em in the house, and, let me see, 57 x's 2 per each of the o.i.c. states, for 539.

why not 10 a year? not a bad start.

john jay

Robert

Sarah Palin, Clarence Thomas, Miguel Estrada, and others like them serve as living proof that supposedly "oppressed minorities" do not need the pompous "rick" politicians to get a fair shake in this society and be able to compete with anyone, completely contrary to the Marxist idiot-ology they have swallowed hook, line, and sinker that says everyone who isn't a white male needs the aid of government officials and is helpless without it, and that they darn well better be grateful for that "help", or else. As those pompous "rick" politicians also tend to be elitists who attended the Ivy League universities and were taught that they are the best and brightest, they probably also hate seeing living proof of any non-white, non-Ivy Leaguer, or woman living a better, more successful life than themselves.

As for duels, I remember a historian on, I believe, the History channel saying that the combatants in duels would usually aim for a non-lethal spot on the opponent, and that duels usually did not result in the death of one of the duellers. Some of the duellers were evidently angry enough with their opponents to shoot to kill, however. I agree it would bring back some civility, or else those who insist on being a-holes would quickly find themselves getting killed off.

JorgXMcKie

You've got the 'Lincoln duel' all wrong. It was huge cavalry sabers in an enclosed space with a board dividing them.
See: http://www.failedsuccess.com/index.php?/weblog/comments/abraham_lincoln_duel/

As a native Illinoisan born on Feb 12 (Lincoln's birthday), I've read quite a bit about him. His 'duel' was an interesting bit of history mostly forgotten until a few years ago.

john jay

jorgxmckie:

my memory is hardly infallible, but my version of the duel is based on carl sandburg's biography of lincoln, which i read in the library of eastern oregon state college, la grande, oregon many years ago.

i have read other accounts, and the board on the barrels has been repeated.

i will look to your link, however, as it should make interesting reading, as does almost everything pertaining to mr. lincoln.

at any rate, the person who challenged lincoln wanted nothing to do with a very long weapon at the end of those very long arms attached to the very long frame. laughing.

as mr. lincoln no doubt fully well intended.

reminds me of a movie, perhaps better forgotten, where the gap toothed english comedian, terry thomas i believe, responded to a challenge to a duel by requesting "balloons and blunderbusses" for weapons.

john jay

p.s. that winter in the easter oregon college library i read all the volumes of sandburg's biography, including the volume of the attached letters of lincoln.

i started out, mostly interested in staying warm, as the rented rooms i stayed in that winter had no heat, nor electricity, except hot water to the bath tub and one outlet near where i spread a sleeping bag and blankets on the floor. i slept in wool socks and a wool watch cap and insulated underwear, and by the time i toweled from bathing, i was red like a lobster from the cold.

nary a single cold that winter. but, i digress.--

i soon became captivated by sandburg, his prose perhaps better than his poetry, ... , or, at least, not a whole lot different from it. it was a lovely read, ... .

to this day, i regard lincoln perhaps the most human & flawed & tragic of all americans, and the greatest public man that we have ever produced.

john jay

p.s. thank you for your comment. always good to continue being educated.

please, come back and read some more, if you are so inclined, and please, more comments.

john jay

jorgxmckie:

i think my memory has to give way to the scholarship and research of your link.

i like my story better. it is more succinct.

but, it would appear the facts are facts and that corrobaration is corrobaration, so i believe that you carry the day.

it is a delightful story, your version, and i had to chuckle and marvel at it several times.

john jay

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)